I'm abiding this sub is overflowing with these posts, but I'd like to accord my assessment on the ratings for my team, the Detroit Lions. Alone traveling to attending at the Lions and area they analyze with the league, if I were to accord my opinions on the abounding ratings I'd be autograph a alternation of novels.
QB: How in the apple is Stafford a 79? I accept endure year was a down year for him, but I don't anticipate anyone would yield Mariota, Dalton or Carr over Stafford. I don't anticipate he should be abundant higher, maybe 82-84, but these added guys should in fact be lower.
HB: I was originally blessed with Kerryon Johnson's rating, until I saw he is the T-31st accomplished rated aback in the game. I get that Kerryon isn't authentic and is all abeyant at this point, but I don't anticipate you could acquisition 30 RBs in the NFL that are bigger appropriate now than KJ. Also, how is KJ slower than CJ Anderson, but stronger? Weird.
WR: Marvin Jones and Kenny Golladay's overalls should be swapped. Marvin is too top at 86, and KG is apparently authentic at 83, maybe a tad low. Amendola and Kearse are way too high.
TE: Annihilation to say here, this position was alright.
OL: Decker could apparently be a brace credibility higher, but 76 isn't bad for him. Ragnow at 79 may be a little high, he had a solid amateur year but he's rated as the 10th LG and T-35th IOL. Also, he will be arena Centermost this year. Glasgow at 74 is appealing solid for him at center, we'll see area he's at afterwards this year afterwards affective aback to guard. Our RG (probably LG in absolute life) is the weakest atom on our roster, so I was assured a low rating. But 2 63 OVRs? I get Wiggins and Aboushi aren't acceptable players, but I anticipate 63 ability be a few credibility too low. Wagner at 77 is fair.
DE: Haven't in fact apparent Flowers play abundant yet, so I'll accede with 87. Da'Shawn Hand at 79 is accurate, but he's an autogenous band player. Madden in fact needs to fix positions and add EDGE. Okwara should apparently be about a 75. He's not a world chic canyon rusher by any means, but he still had 7.5 sacks as a 23 year old.
DT: Snacks at 95 is fair. He adapted our defense, and he aswell got 3.5 sacks in 9 amateur here. Not bad for a run-stopping DT. They nailed this one. A'Shawn at 77 is fair.
OLB: Fair.
ILB: Jarrad Davis should apparently be college than 72. He hasn't lived up to his aboriginal annular cachet yet, but he had a actual solid end to endure division and was starting to attending good. I anticipate 75 would be a acceptable all-embracing for him. Tavai at 69 is probably fair.
CB: Slay got hoed. Slay is apparently a top-5 CB in the NFL appropriate now and he got rated as T-7th at 89 OVR. Slay abaft Byron Jones and Richard Sherman? Nah. I ability be biased but Slay is bigger than them, and 100% deserves a 90+ OVR.
Rashaan Melvin ability be a little top at 78, and Justin Coleman ability be a little low at 77. Afterwards those 3 the ratings attending fair.
S: Diggs at 77 ability be a tad low, but it's not bad. Annihilation to accuse about. Wilson at 76 is apparently high. I wish to say Tracy Walker at 72 is fair because of his bound activity endure season, but his bound activity was terrific. I know the Madden guys are big into PFF, and Walker was a PFF darling. Affectionate of afraid to see them put him at 72, I would accept anticipation they'd accord him a 75ish. Miles Killebrew is too high. Rest are fine.
P/K: Prater should apparently be college than 78. Sam Martin should apparently be college than 75.
Feel chargeless to acquaint me how biased and amiss I am, I'm accessible for it haha. Also, who on your aggregation was under/overrated?